Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes review

  • Competitive online mode is a blast
  • HD audio/ visual is very impressive
  • Balance tweaks make it more competitive
  • Long and frequent load times
  • Single player campaign gets pretty stale
  • All of that time you lost while playing

Here’s the thing: five years ago, if you were to tell us that puzzle games deep fried in RPG batter were going to spawn their own subgenre, we probably would have called you bat-poop nutso and laughed in your face. Now that Puzzle Quest is out, good, and ubiquitous, it spawned the worst thing about a subgenre: endless rip-offs. We can’t really blame it, though; eventually, a developer with its own bit of moxie will figure out how to spin the new formula on its head and crank out a game that was not only truly unique, but also the bar-setting benchmark.

People of the internet: that game has come, it’s called Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes, and you can download it for $15.

More than simply a graphically - enhanced port of the 2009 sleeper DS game, Clash of Heroes is a content-packed puzzle/RPG/strategy hybrid that will leave most of you scratching your heads wondering why nobody figured this out a long time ago. An easy game to pick up and play but compelling enough to keep you coming back with its competitive online modes and brief Quick Battles, the cash that you drop on this game is a small price to pay compared to the amount of time you’ll lose on playing it.

The game is split into three primary modes: a campaign mode that follows five different characters through a somewhat stock fantasy RPG story, a quick battle mode that lets you skip the jibber jabber and get right into the fighting, and an online multiplayer mode that allows both coop and competitive play with 2v2 and 1v1 battles. While the RPG-like campaign may be where most players start for a brief training lesson and even some story to go along with their puzzling, it’s the battles that make the game tick. Even though they’re better experienced than described, we’ll do our best to lay it out for you.

The playfield is split lengthwise down the middle, separating your troops from your opponent. Your units, categorized into three colors, pepper the field at the beginning of a battle randomly, meaning that you’re going to have to move some immediately to set up your attacks and defenses. Calling in your reserve units also brings them in randomly, and depending on where they arrive, you could be at a great advantage or disadvantage indiscriminant of how thoughtfully you placed your troops beforehand. This is how the puzzle elements work best: the feeling of chance that can dictate your tactics, and the keen observation it takes to play it into your favor.

Color-coded units must be placed in rows or columns to be anything other than sitting targets. By placing three simple units in a column formation, your combatants will begin a charging phase, granting them extra defense. Each different unit has its own amount of turns it needs to charge before launching their offensive move. Ultimately, the attack needs to hit the back line behind their opponent’s army to do any damage to them (think direct damage in Magic: The Gathering); if enemy units or walls are in the way, your attack could diminish or be blocked altogether.

You can set up this kind of defense yourself by placing the same colored units next to each other in rows of three or more, turning them into walls. Each different main character’s walls have its own unique properties (such as certain walls healing themselves between rounds and others that more easily stack for added defense), which can make the need to judge your attacks and plan offensive strategies completely different from one opponent to the next. Since most units in the game do not attack immediately, the strategy comes from knowing where you can deal direct damage to the opponent, knock out higher-level enemies from their charges, or where you might get stymied either way.

The cost to all of this, of course, is allowance. Each side of the battlefield can only make three decisions per turn to add or subtract where their units are placed. Picking up and moving a fighter, deleting one off of the field, and calling in reinforcements all take one decision away from you, so its up to the player to either work with or against the randomized location of the individual combatants.

The advantage to this brings us back to the puzzle-like structure of the game. If units are placed in such a way that only one of an off color is inhibiting the formation of an attack or wall, deleting it won’t cost a decision. If, by doing so, a chain of attacks or walls is formed following the deletion, bonus movements are awarded. Since attacks and walls can be stacked and chained together to form more powerful versions of each other, careful and observant players are rewarded by dishing out harder punishment behind impregnable fortresses.

The other real cost of it all is the other real allowance: your time. Not to put too fine a point on it, but Clash of Heroes is almost alarming in the amount of content that it offers. The RPG-esque campaign mode is split up into five chapters and follows one of the generals through a standard high fantasy adventure. Each different subsection can last anywhere from three to seven hours apiece, though, and even though the campaigns offer variation on the actual battles (more puzzle-like bouts where the amount of turns is limited and battles with bosses that are moving targets, for example), going all the way through can make things a little tedious.

While it is fun (at least, at first), everything about the campaign seems to point you toward playing competitively online. Finishing each section of the story unlocks various artifacts with different, battle-changing abilities, new generals with their own unique special attacks, and a unique high-level troop to take online and play in 1v1 or 2v2 dominance. During the story sections, each character – as they would in any RPG – starts at a low level with a minimal amount of troops to call into battle and very little when it comes to unit variation. The online modes do away with that altogether by starting both generals and their units at their level cap with the option of bringing in what they are rewarded with by toughing through the campaign.

For the most part, finding online matches is a painless process. Standard hosting, searching, and quick matches are all there, but lobbies are noticeably absent as are spectator options. Since this isn’t really the kind of game that necessarily demands those, we can give Capybara a pass on this one. Still, players won’t have any trouble finding some fitting (and stable) competition on whatever console they choose to play it on.

This online matchmaking mode is also the main difference between the new HD remake and its handheld predecessor, but you may not even know it. The graphics looks great in high definition: monsters and knights alike animate fluidly and look crisp, and the widescreen format brings out subtle nuances like flowing scarves and waiving hair that would be tough to see in the palm of your hand. Compared to the audio, though, the graphics are just a minor upgrade. The music in this downloadable version of the game showcases rousing battle themes and even moving character motifs that the DS couldn’t come close to matching. Trust us: the music is worth the fifteen bones alone. Certain minor tweaks were also made to some units’ attack and defense properties. While most of these are nerfs, it doesn’t curb the fun of the game in any way.

Load times are also somewhat frequent and can feel a bit lengthy. While this is kind of a small potatoes complaint given the greatness of the overall package, it isn’t so uncommon that you’ll click on your next battle and wander off to grab a drink while it does its thing.

So far, this has been a pretty darn good year for games in general, and especially for downloadable ones. Stuff like Stacking, Beyond Good and Evil HD, and Torchlight for XBLA are setting pretty high standards for what’s available electronically for consoles. Might & Magic: Clash of Heroes stands proudly in that lineup. Not only does it stack up to its handheld counterpart, the online multiplayer and upgraded audio/visuals help exceed it.

Apr 26, 2011

More Info

Release date: Apr 13 2011 - Xbox 360
Dec 01 2009 - DS
Apr 12 2011 - PS3 (US)
Apr 13 2011 - Xbox 360
Jan 22 2010 - DS
Apr 12 2011 - PS3 (UK)
Available Platforms: Xbox 360, iPad, DS, PS3
Genre: Strategy
Published by: Ubisoft
Developed by: Capybara Games
Franchise: Heroes of Might and Magic
ESRB Rating:
Everyone 10+: Mild Fantasy Violence, Mild Suggestive Themes, Mild Language
PEGI Rating:


Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000