Is Luke a gray Jedi in Star Wars 8? Let’s examine the evidence

You know how the Force works in Star Wars. There’s a light side and a dark side, and they spend most of their time giving each other serious stink eye across the galaxy while occasionally chopping bits off each other. Hands, mainly. Both really have a thing for hands. 

However, that wasn’t always the way and might not be in the future if fan theories about the ‘gray Force’ turn out to be true. It appears that since Disney restarted the franchise and took it away from George ‘taxation of trade routes’ Lucas, it’s been adding mentions to this idea everywhere. The Star Wars Rebels series, Rogue One and numerous supporting books are gently reinforcing the idea that the gray Force is a thing. 

Most fans are wondering why Disney would go to all this effort to introduce a new concept so ubiquitously without an end plan. Plus, there are rumours that Luke Skywalker wears gray Jedi robes in Star Wars 8 with a Sith-like shawl. The combination of that, other mentions and a few crucial references in The Force Awakens and Rogue One make many believe that Star Wars 8 and 9 will introduce the idea of a new kind of Force user, balancing both sides. 

For example, The Force Awakens’ big bads, Supreme Leader Snoke and Kylo Ren, are clearly dark side Force users but not Sith. Kylo also says at one point “I feel it again... the call from the light,” which is not something you expect from a pure dark sider. Plus, no one currently even knows what a ‘Knight of Ren’ actually is. Was Luke trying to train a new form of Jedi and failed to get the balance quite right?  

But let’s backtrack a moment here. This isn’t just Disney making stuff up for a surprise twist in the films. It does tie back into some of George Lucas’ very early ideas for Star Wars. When he was working up the first versions of the story it was originally going to be told by immortal creatures known as the Whills. The concept didn’t stick but the idea of an overseeing universal presence became the Force. This is important because in Rogue One, Chirrut Îmwe is a Guardian of the Whills, at the temple in Jedha, reinstating the concept into film canon (the Whills were also mentioned in the prequels). 

The Rogue One Visual Guide (which is also canon) expands on Chirrut, but more importantly the Whills. It explains that the Whills’ teachings did not emphasise a discord between the different sides of the Force and instead focused on encompassing the totality of the Force. Then there’s the official novelisation of The Force Awakens, which starts with a quote from the Journal of the Whills: 

"First comes the day
Then comes the night.
After the darkness
Shines through the light.
The difference, they say,
Is only made right
By the resolving of gray
Through refined Jedi sight."
Journal of the Whills, 7:477

That basically suggests a cycle of good, bad, light, dark, and then balance. Is the Luke the refined Jedi mentioned “resolving the gray?” Has he become a gray Jedi? The idea of a gray Jedi is actually peppered throughout Star Wars lore to different degrees, both canon and non-canon, referring to everything from Jedi that don’t play well with the high council (like the prequel’s Qui-Gon Jinn) to characters that are a blend of both sides of the Force. Wookieepedia defines this by saying “gray Jedi called on the dark side of the Force, but were not corrupted by it.” 

Then there’s Bendu, a huge,  armoured cow-like character from Star Wars Rebel’s second and third season. He’s an ancient Force user who describes himself as ‘in the middle’ of the light and dark, awoken by an imbalance. Again, this is Disney working in old elements of Lucas’ ideas. Like one early name for the Jedi, the Jedi-Bendu. He also played around with names like ‘Ashla’ and ‘Bogan’ for light and dark, which are now the names of two moons around Typhon, home of an early Je'daii Order that studied a more balanced version of the Force. Je’daii that strayed too far to one side or the other were sent to the relevent moon to meditate and restore balance - Ashla for the Light and Bogan for the Dark. 

Perhaps the biggest clue is the title of Episode 8: The Last Jedi. Fans have gone crazy trying to work out if it’s singular or plural; Luke, Rey or both? Kylo? Does it mean an end to the Jedi order? Or just the order as we currently know it? If the gray Force hints being built up at the moment come to pass then it could be more of a transitional thing. A new kind of Jedi replacing the old. Remember, Anakin/Vader was the chosen one, supposed to bring balance to the Force. Maybe he will, just not with direct action during his lifetime. The lasting ripples could be enough, driving Luke and Kylo to pursue a new kind of belief. 

Then, for a final kicker, there’s Snoke, again, an apparently ancient Force user with no clear discipline. Given the long and varied history of different orders and Force-wielders perhaps he’s already the last Jedi by his own beliefs? That’s perhaps a theory for another day. The key thing here is that Disney are doing a lot of prep to make people comfortable with the idea that light and dark isn’t the only way to use the Force and, come Episode 8, we might find out why.

[Update] There is a counterpoint to all this that I completely forgot to add from my notes (trust me, this is a rabbit hole). Pablo Hidalgo, who has been the lore master for Star Wars, tweeted this:  

It could be a denial. However, a lot of what I've read involves numerous variations of what a Jedi can be, both in terms of concept and spelling. Plus Bendu is very much not a Jedi but 'in the middle' of the light and the dark. The term 'Jedi' might not apply in the future for a Force wielder (possibly another word?) but the idea of an option neither light not dark still does. 

We recommend