Quantcast

Why 3D is the new HD

We've gone eyes-on with the new generation of 3D gaming. Here's why it IS the future

Words: David Houghton, GamesRadar UK

3D is just a tacky hold-over from the 1950s, right? A garish, eye-straining gimmick that makes your brain vomit up a rainbow of fruit flavours in exchange for a few pop-up zombies on sticks. It was cinema’s desperate knee-jerk reaction to the increasing dominance of TV during the chrome-plated days of white picket fences and Godzilla. Today it’s Jim Cameron’s desperate knee-jerk reaction to the increasing dominance of bit torrents.

Yeah, that’s what we used to think too. But not any more.

 

Above: Impressive cosplay, but not the 3D gaming we're talking about

After a lengthy play with developer Blitz Games Studios’ upcoming 3D tech in Invincible Tiger: The Legend of Han Tao, scheduled by publisher Namco Bandai for release this September, our doubts have dissipated. 3D isn’t going to revolutionise gaming overnight, but even at this early stage we can see very definite parallels between it and the beginnings of a certain other display technology ending in “D”. The comparisons to the early days of high-def are obvious, and we think 3D’s future will only compound them. Here’s why.


It makes games better - Fact

It’s easy to be cynical when the man developing the new technology tells you that you haven’t experienced real 3D media before. It’s easy to be nonplussed when he mocks the red-and-blue paper specs of old before presenting you with a chunky pair of plastic sunglasses in replacement. But the fact is that the claims are true. This new 3D just makes games a hell of a lot cooler, to an order of magnitude which will force you to sit back and out-“Woah” Keanu Reeves even at his most bamboozled.

Above: We tried to do a clever Photoshop turning this screen into a 3D model. We failed hard.

Blitz’s tech isn’t the blurry, flat parallax layers of old. It’s a sharp, solid and real-feeling experience; as much like remotely manipulating a 3D diorama as playing a game. The example we played was Invincible Tiger, Blitz’s upcoming 2.5D kung fu side-scroller, but even without a multi-directional world to explore the improvement over a ‘flat’ display was immense. Little men fought in the middle of the screen, the ground they stood on stretched right up to the background scenery, and every building, bridge, rock and tree root fell into multi-directional relief exactly as it should.

And best of all, it never felt gimmicky. Blitz has very stringent rules on how to use this stuff properly, and those rules come from the perspectives of both logistics and taste. Most importantly, the depth of field went into the screen, not out of it, turning the TV into a kind of window frame overlooking the game’s staging area. No cheesy pop-up zombies here.

Above: The depth of field in scenes like this really does make it feel real. Just squint and try to imagine it.

That approach solved the problem of viewers' brains melting down when watching out-of-screen 3D images reach the edge of the viewing area (not a problem in cinemas, but a nightmare at home where viewing angles can vary). But it also made sure that the experience was all about in-game immersion rather than cheap tricks. The only extravagant effect was a smile-inducing out-of-screen throw, which saw enemies’ flailing bodies sail a foot or so out of the TV from time to time. Even the ship we watched sail a few hundred in-game metres from the horizon to the foreground was much more about adding texture and a sense of reality scale to the game world than simply saying “Look what we can do”.


 
47 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
KillDrone  - 4 months 17 days ago 
I think we can skip the 3D step and just go straight to virtual reality. I don't really need to be completely immersed in the game that I'm playing by having it look like I'm really getting shot at.
kubes  - 4 months 17 days ago 
i sort of agree with kill drone but 3D has gone from spy kids 3 to Coraline and it has been a huge improvement

Recaptcha: In Playtex
GamesRadarBrettElston  - 4 months 17 days ago 
ZAMN cosplay ftw
Nin10DOH  - 4 months 17 days ago 
agreed with killdrone. Im sure Nintendo would be the first with virtual reality
maybe a less fail virtual boy?
nyef  - 4 months 17 days ago 
idk 3d could be a great idea... or epic fail in my opinion

nice addition of zombies ate my neighbors, thought everyone forgot about it

......third.... meh
nyef  - 4 months 17 days ago 
not third... wow im dumb

reCAPTCHA: been triple
jammyhippo  - 4 months 17 days ago 
im not going to pay for another t.v just to play in 3D, not you know theres a credit crunch on? thats said Brink in 3D could be pretty sexy.

reCAPTCHA Chiming Khan
number1hitjam  - 4 months 17 days ago 
I like how the 3D goes into the screen rather than out. I think tasteful use of 3D could actually work.

I also can't help thinking "sixaxis" when I see this
Rodrigo90  - 4 months 17 days ago 
"will force you to sit back and out-“Woah” Keanu Reeves"

You SOB you really made me laugh there xD that was great (Y)
garnsr  - 4 months 17 days ago 
Do you need to have glasses to even look at the screen while 3D is on? It's impossible to watch 3D movies without the glasses, but everyone in the theater has the glasses going in. Not everyone in the living room will have glasses, so bystanders (especially girlfriends) are even more likely to bitch about you playing games, since it will make them sick watching the screen with no glasses.
Mackster-901  - 4 months 17 days ago 
3d on the most powerful console (ps3) will look quality
GoldenMe  - 4 months 17 days ago 
Ehh, boring article.

I think I'll pass this.
crumbdunky  - 4 months 17 days ago 
My mate was at GDC and TGS and played GT:P in 3D, or watched it demoed I can't recall which, and said that I wouldn't believe how good it was-and he's like a super cynic!

Sony then told him they were using old tech that will NEVER go to market so lord only knows what the tech they will bring to us is like! While I'm not dying to play in 3D I'm def more interested than I thought I would be-just as long as the software works as well for HD as 3D so they aren't almost forcing new TV's on gamers.
Luiman04  - 4 months 17 days ago 
i agree with KillDrone but i dont think nintendo will be the first to do it
fionnoh  - 4 months 17 days ago 
christ, gaming is already bad enough on your eyes. we don't need 3-D to make it worse, imagine trying really hard to focus on something in the back round that the game insists on keeping blurry. ugh...
Mushroomer  - 4 months 17 days ago 
I disagree with something like StarCraft not using 3D well. Zoomed-out presentation with your units lifted off the screen? It would be a huge step in immersion.

At the same time, how will this fit in with our other gaming future - motion control? 3D usually works best from one stationary viewpoint - moving around may eff up the picture. Full head-tracking is an option, but it doesn't work for more than 1 person.

I say that Playstation will be the first to really try this. They really show themselves as THE HD console, with the best processing power - so I think they'll jump on this new generation of visuals first as an upgrade to the PS3.
iKOemos  - 4 months 17 days ago 
GODDAMN IT! A new TV upgrade already? Well hopefully it'll be worth it and not some useless gimmick that people don't buy into.
civver  - 4 months 17 days ago 
Still not impressed. Personally, an immersive experience isn't the be all and end all of gaming for me. I thought motion control would be fantastic, but I don't even use my Wii nowadays. I don't even care about HD, I'm fine playing games on a standard definition set. I guess I'm not just that impressed by shiny stuff.
pedro  - 4 months 17 days ago 
http://www.physorg.com/news166186470.html

These people may be on to something
doomdoomdoom  - 4 months 17 days ago 
nintendo doesn't deserve 3d
ps3, pc, and xbox deserve 3D because they try to give realism to gaming 3d will help a lot.

The Wii should die and burn for it's sins like taking realism away and trying to make fat people sit in front of tv more by make them think they are losing weight.

They are as bad as Diet drinks, have you ever seen a fat person lose weight from those?
Related Games
'Calling' Box Art Revealed N4G
Wii News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
New Hello Kitty Game Ships to Retailers N4G
DS News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
Jenny McCarthy's Wii Game Released to Retailers N4G
Wii News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
Red Dead Redemption trailer dated N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
Nintendo considered releasing an "enhanced... N4G
DS News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009