Quantcast

The Top 7... Bitter rivalries

Take it outside, you two!

Words: GamesRadar US

Super Mario Bros. (Nintendo) versus Sonic the Hedgehog (Sega)

Choosing sides: The character you picked in this bitter rivalry may well have decided who your friends were. In one corner you've got Mario, always doing something fun and silly, be it throwing fireballs, wearing a cape or growing a raccoon tail. But in the other corner is a fast 'n' furious speedster who's actually got a personality. He's new, he's edgy, he's everything Mario isn't. The games didn't play anything alike, but that didn't stop the entire planet from enduring this intense 10-year face-off.

Highlights: Mario reigned supreme through the NES days, but in 1991, everything came into question. The cute and cheery ways of SNES megapower Super Mario World were actually facing competition from a foot-tapping rival that emphasized excitement over exploration. Sonic didn't want you to dick around looking for warp zones and secret coins, he wanted you to RUN and RUN some more. RUN through a loop, RUN for some rings, RUN to the boss, then RUN to the next level. Always move forward, who cares about what's behind, right? These two distinctly different philosophies cut the gaming community in half. You were a Nintendo gamer or you were a Sega gamer, and that was it. People would spit, throw things, even take a swing or two if you said their platform sucked. It was unheard of then, and such an intense difference of gaming opinion has never since appeared. We are so glad internet forums did not exist in 1992. If people were willing to get into physical fights, what kind of insanity would have broken out thanks to the anonymity of the web?

The outcome: After Sega's numerous hardware losses (Sega CD, 32X, Saturn, Dreamcast), not even Sonic was cool enough to buoy the entire company. Even his reputation has fallen, a meteoric downward spiral filled with awful supporting characters, terrible gameplay and utterly idiotic storylines. Still, Nintendo fans bought Sonic titles in droves when they appeared on the GameCube, ensuring the franchise's future. Sega and Nintendo are now pretty tight, as evidenced by the upcoming Mario and Sonic at the Olympic Games and the successful GBA and DS Sonic titles. The once angriest of foes are now practically best buds.

The only sour point to this story is that there has yet to be a definitive victor in a one-on-one fight between Mario and Sonic, and the 2008 Olympic Games are not the venue we want to see the feud settled at. Rumors continue to fly that Sonic may appear in Super Smash Bros. Brawl. If that's the case, it'll be Nintendo who wins this decade-long battle - the sales from Brawl alone could keep Wii afloat for years to come.

To read GamesRadar's other Top 7 countdowns, click here.


 
31 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
cultofbananas  - 1 year 1 month ago 
Wow. I hate EA more than ever... I knew they had some sort of corrupt hand in buying out the NFL, but 15 YEARS?!?!
Monkeylink  - 11 months 25 days ago 
Mario And Sonic Have been competing since they were made And they both SUCK
ryno  - 11 months 23 days ago 
i like resident evil better than silent hill
pyro9393  - 11 months 17 days ago 
sonic and mario rule but only the orginals and id take re over sh any day
Teh_Ty  - 9 months 22 days ago 
1. Resident Evil I tred both for about an hour and Resident evil was over all better.

2. I don't know, haven't tried either. I would like to try both though.

3. Street fighter, I've played each one in arcades and I like street fighter because of the colorful characters and it was just plain more fun to play. The spoofs were cool also.

4. No idea. I don't play sports games. They're all the sam in my opinion.

5.Tekken. I've played all the versions a couple times and tekken, once again, had the memorable characters and moves. Like yoshimitsu, or that one guy made out of wood [Forgot his name]

6.Final Fantasy nintendo. I always liked the class system and the earlier ones such as the original and the ones that have recently come to the DS and game boy advance. My overall favorite, tactics series on Game boy advance and Ds. And last but not least...
7. Super mario brothers. sonic has gone down after it's best game, sonic 2:battle.
explicit56  - 9 months 22 days ago 
silent hill makes me sick but thats the best part of it, but as far as riddles, plot-tiwsts, and edge-of-seat action i always choose resident evil.

i dont play sports games i think they suck and i suck at them so i dont care about how evil EA is.

mario is the best. i say that because thats what i grew up playing i never paid attention to SEGA at all. also, the t.v. series for sonic is just embarasing to watch its so ridiculous.

mortal Kombat is my favorite, i never heard of street fighter till i read that article (LoL)
jesusfrk15  - 9 months 22 days ago 
i think sonic is alot better then mario. i mean C'MON! he's a friggen fat plumber, versus the fastest animal on the planet, and for a bonus, he can talk. and i never really played any of the other games, but by what ive heard about silent hill and residen evil, and by the trailers i think silent hill is better, but as i said i have no experience with either...and i loved the silent hill movie
noobeater  - 9 months 21 days ago 
im sorry but i think mario hands down beats sonic be it then or now (certainly now) oh and i by far prefer mortal combat

however with resi v silent hill ...silent hills which i have only recently played its more tough....silent hill is terrifing but i think resident evil is more fun

good article
SKStorm  - 9 months 20 days ago 
I think Halo 3 vs Call of duty4 should of been there
gutlessVADER  - 9 months 20 days ago 
wat u like sucks wat i like rules i hate u adn wat u like
GamesRadarBrettElston  - 9 months 19 days ago 
Just keep in mind this was posted in July 2007, months before either CoD4 or Halo 3 were out. Still had a lot of fun with it though. It's also from the old site design, hence the many pages instead the now-standard four.
Toprockerturner94  - 9 months 18 days ago 
resi is definately better i have never got on with silent hill its pants!
Toprockerturner94  - 9 months 18 days ago 
street fighter is the best. though mortal kombat is good for its fatality's and fighting humor street fighter for me has the edge over mortal kombat
Toprockerturner94  - 9 months 18 days ago 
tekken rocks its definately the best fighter ever.ive only ever played virtua fighter on the sega master system and i didnt enjoy it
Toprockerturner94  - 9 months 18 days ago 
ive never played final fantasy nintendo so i'll have to go for sony
Toprockerturner94  - 9 months 18 days ago 
oooooooooo i real tough one but ill have to go for sonic
kingofdanger  - 9 months 15 days ago 
You're not even gonna mention the Alpha series? Come on, SFA3 was the best Street Fighter game of them all.
ShAnWOW  - 8 months 8 days ago 
Winners Are:
Resident Evil
Quake
Mortal Kombat
EA Sports
Virtua Fighter
Final Fantasy Sony
Sonic
theworms3d  - 8 months 8 days ago 
im a total silent hill fan me and my older brother stayed up many a nights taking turns with that, scariest and best game ever

and im a true sonic fan all the way marios good but sonic is a timeless legend and ive beat every one of his games except the newest one
Awesomeitude1523  - 8 months 8 days ago 
No ShAn WOW The Real Winner are

Silent Hill
Unreal
Street Fighter
In NFL and MLB, EA. In NBA and NHL, 2K sports
Tekken
Final Fantasy Sony ( You got ONE right)
Mario ( Sonic Riders : WTF)
Related Games
PC
PC
Wii
Wii
PSP
PSP
Xbox 360
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Gamecube
GameCube
PC
PC
Wii
Wii
PSP
PSP
Xbox 360
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Gamecube
GameCube
Play the original Quake in your browser N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
PSLS Giveaway: 50 Battlefield Bad Company 2 Beta... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
PixelJunk Shooter Aiming for Release Date N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
CONFIRMED: God Of War Collection Coming To EU... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009
Over 1,000 songs now available for Rock Band N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 25, 2009