Quantcast

QOTW: What was the first movie game that made you hate movie games?

Answer our weekly question and check out our favorite user answers from last week!

Words: Tyler Wilde, GamesRadar US

Every week the hosts of TalkRadar present and answer a new "Question of the Week" - a personal inquiry which unearths some of our deepest, and sometimes most sinister, gaming memories. Everyone is encouraged to answer each week's question, so go ahead, tell us your most glorious, nostalgic, or shameful story!


This week's question:

What was the first movie game that made you hate movie games?

We can all thank Brett Elston for a question of the week that is immensely difficult to convey concisely. So - what movie game first clued you in to the fact that movie games are generally known for being crappy? We've probably all, at some point, picked up a movie game that we had high hopes for ("Yes! A Total Recall game for the NES!"), and were horribly disappointed ("Oh..."). Which sad experience stuck with you the most?

Answer this week's question in the comments!

Questions can also be answered in the QOTW forum thread. Our favorite posts this week will be read next week on TalkRadar 61, and appear in the next edition of this article. Listen to TalkRadar 60 on Friday for our answers!


Last week's question:

What is your all-time favorite console?

Number-fiend Brett Elston actually took the time to count the forum responses to last week's question and tally a score. The winner? PlayStation 2! Congratulations PS2, we still love you.

Below are a few of last week's answers that tickled our collective fancies, but since we can't feature them all here, check out last week's article and forum thread for more...



zymn wrote...
"the NES. what other console can you go back to after years and years and STILL enjoy playing it? you can't do that with a PS1, cause the pixelly 3D makes you wanna barf. you can't do it with an Atari, cause it makes your eyes bleed now, and you can't do it with a dog. cause that's unnatural."

 



Corsair89 wrote...
"The N64 was my childhood. I owned only about a dozen games for years and was happy to play them. And I didn't even own Super Mario 64 or The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Nowadays, I play about a dozen games a month and get a dozen more the next month."



elchetos wrote...
"I have to say the PS1. I missed the entire 16 bit generation, it was my first console after the NES. Not only I had a great time playing games with it, and I also learned english (I'm mexican, it helped me avoid getting the funny accent). I played the hell out of MGS and FFVIII, so that helped a lot. It is because of it that I'm writing my undergrad thesis on the useof video games as a teaching tool..."


Above: Educational!



dweller wrote...
"Sega Genesis is my all time favorite console. I played the shit out of Sonic 2 and Contra Hard Corps.

Plus I played Phantasy Star 4 many times to make that initial $100 price tag worth it. It was great anyways, but beating it in 5 days made me feel bad as a kid."



loonyman978 wrote...
"The Sega Mega Drive, because it was my first ever console which I'd got at a car boot sale for a fiver. It also introduced me to sonic the hedgehog, who I still hate today :)"



TrigunGunner wrote...
"Mine is the DS hands down. That's because lately there's been a swarm of great RPG games on the DS. My PS2 is still nice, but the last fantastic game that came out for the PS2 was Persona 4 and that was in January. I still play it a lot, but the fact that only a few games come out for it now, the PS2 is the runner up. My least favorite console is the Wii. My Wii (which my parents bought for the Wii sports they never play) is busy collecting dust waiting for Muramasa: the Demon Blade to actually come out so I will actually play the stupid thing again."



Jul 16, 2009

To see the rest of the stories, check out our previous QOTW articles, and for more podcast related discussion, introduce yourself in the TalkRadar forums.

New episodes of TalkRadar post every Friday afternoon, and can be found on iTunes or as features here on GamesRadar. We archive every TalkRadar episode in the TalkRadar Compendinarium.


 
116 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
louiec314  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Street Fighter The movie-The Game...the worst fighter to ever grace a TV screen til Kabuki Warriors
JohnnyMaverik  - 4 months 6 days ago 
O.o... No comments yet, but I wont say it -_-

Strange not to see the SNES on there, always held a special place in my heart anyway.

As for the first movie game that made me hate movies games, I'd have to say the First Harry Potter movie to game adaptation... wasnt aweful but wasn't anything special, just depressingly slap bang avarage. I was only about 12 at the time and I'd enjoyed the Phantom Menace game, but The Philosopher's stone made me weary of movie games ever since.

Also it was kinda bizzare to consider it was the game adaptation of a movie adaptation of a book. I can only think of a couple of Lord of the Rings games that can also be placed in that category although I'm probably missing out some glaringly obvious ones.
ChrisAntistaSmellsLikePizza  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Peter Jackson's King Kong the Offical Game of the Movie. F' you Gameloft, I didn't like the movie and I hated the game even more. Good for achievement whoring however.
Cyberninja  - 4 months 6 days ago 
none i dont play movie because they all suck end of story.
Darth Olds  - 4 months 6 days ago 
I'm going with the number one craptacular movie game of all time. E.T. The Extraterrestrial. My father bought it for me when it came out on the Atari 2600 and yes I played it through. It was a crappy game even given the time it was created in. Very simple game play, had almost nothing to do with the movie plot, lousy controls, and the pits. Oh the pits! I can never look at a hole dug in the earth the same ever again.

Though I wonder if E.T. could levitate himself out of the pits why did he fall in them to begin with? And if I remember right I think it took like 10 minutes to beat the game providing you didn't fall into the pit.
MechGyver  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Wrong question. Unfortunatly they all end up sucking for one reason or another, but i guess its because its like comparing between watching a movie and making part of it. you can“t beat interaction, its the diference between watching a porno or having sex, which would you enjoy the most?
KHfan  - 4 months 6 days ago 
enter the matrix is the worst movie video game i think, there is no story line and the graphics are rubbish =P it could of been a great game if they had only put a little effort into it
secretsearcher  - 4 months 6 days ago 
C-c-c-c-Combo breaker!!!
Dexsus  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Hmm, so hard to to remember which one made me hate them all....I'd have to say Gremlins 2: The New Batch for the gameboy. I remember playing that and seeing that little gimp Gizmo, Damn him! Him and them huge ears, horrible platformer.
secretsearcher  - 4 months 6 days ago 
But seriously, I don't play movie games anyway. I buy every Harry Potter game that comes out because I love the books and the movie, but other than that, I know to stay away from movie games. It's hardwired into most gamer's DNA from the start.
Pepsuber88  - 4 months 6 days ago 
I liked the first 2 Harry Potter entries for GBC, since they were RPGs, but the 3rd entry made me go cry to a corner and think of suicide for a while.
secretsearcher  - 4 months 6 days ago 
And I will be buying Revenge of the Fallen. But that's a rare exception.

P.S. Three comments. Sorry about that.
Soulieth  - 4 months 6 days ago 
A early game I remember that put me off movie games was Jurrasic park on SNES. I was about 5 or 6 at the time so I was useless at games and couldn't get anywhere, I could only play for about 15 minutes before having to start back at the beginning. It didn't help either that I was really scared of dinosaurs espically in the 3D parts. To be honest it wasn't really a bad game, but it did put me off movie games.

The movie game that really put me off movie games was TOYS on snes, the film with robin williams. All I remember about it was that it was terrible and it has to be bad because I loved power rangers.
Snarf  - 4 months 6 days ago 
I have never seen one because I am smart enough to not go see one. But I can safely say it will be the Bioshock or Gears of War movie that will do the trick.
elchetos  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Oh dear... From Fester's quest to the gazillion Harry Potter games, going through the Die Hard trilogy, Enter the Matrix, the Gremlins games... they're all bad... BAD!!! (With the few exceptions... rare exceptions). I think games based on movies should be treated as people with leprosy long ago (Put a yellow hood on them and make them walk with a stick full of bells or something that makes noise, so people know they should stay away from them)
DaNtHeManIsHeRe  - 4 months 6 days ago 
spiderman 3.

it was such a shame as the seccond one was just what id wanted it to be (minus balloon fetching missions), butthis edition not only added nothing, but actualy ruined the brilliance of number 2 with its terrible graphics, blundering plot and lame ass bosses.
tehsandvich  - 4 months 6 days ago 
I realy cant say any ive never played a bad movie games im lucky enough only to ever play the good ones :D The worst one ive played so far would have been batman for the nes god that was freaking impossible.
CuddlyBomber  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Maybe this isn't a movie game but when I first got my 360 I was really exited for Star Trek Legacy. Nuff said.
oryandymackie  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Who comes up with these questions? They're a bit generic, succeeded in naffness only by "what kind of music do you like?" Come on people, think outside the box!
Brettbot  - 4 months 6 days ago 
Die Hard on the NES. Seeing Bruce Willis get his ass kicked was kinda depressing.
Related Games
Xbox 360
Xbox 360
Visceral hits back at Dante's Inferno critics N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Mythic guys do damage control N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Shantae: Risky's Revenge pushed back into 2010 N4G
DS News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Divinity II pre-order program begins N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
BeefJack - Music DLC Roundup - 21/11 N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009