Quantcast

LucasArts vs Sierra Part Two: The Remembering

Who made the best adventures games? We look back on the most beloved point-and-clickers of all time

Words: Tyler Nagata, GamesRadar US

E3 is fast approaching. But right now, our thoughts are still stuck on the works of past designers like Roberta Williams, Al Lowe, Ron Gilbert, and Tim Schaefer. That’s why a few weeks ago, we looked back on the grand age of adventure games, when LucasArts and Sierra produced some of the most memorable point-and-clickers of all time. As we approached the late 80s, it looked like Sierra was far ahead with great titles like King’s Quest, Police Quest, Space Quest, and Leisure Suit Larry in its library. But before we could declare the early 80s as a landslide victory for Sierra, team Lucas struck back with the release of Maniac Mansion, one of the most hilarious and loved adventure games of all time. So join us as we say goodbye to the last great adventures of the 80s, and say hello to the best Sierra and LucasArts adventures of the 90s.

 


Above: Sierra’s in the lead with a cotton gin and two Gelflings. But LucasArts has a David Bowie and Bruce Campbell. It’s still anyone’s game 

Does our amazing scoring system confound you? Don’t worry. Just head here to catch up on what went down in part one of our retrospective.

 


Zak McKracken and the Alien Mindbenders
Lucasfilm Games
Released: 1988

Lucasfilms’ second adventure game that used their proprietary SCUMM engine introduced adventurers to Francis Zachary McKracken, a tabloid reporter who finds himself roped into a quest to save Earth from hostile aliens who want to make humans dumber than they already are.


Above: Zakku Makkurakken-san sure looks in the Japanese version of the game


Above: You’ll find out that Elvis is an alien along with other “truths” that tinfoil-hat-wearing conspiracy theorists have known for years 


King’s Quest IV: The Perils of Rosella
Sierra
Released: 1988

The fourth entry in the King’s Quest series introduced Princess Rosella, one of the first major adventure game protagonists to be widely recognized for her lack of a penis. The game sent you on a quest to the land Tamir to search for a magical fruit that could heal King Graham, who suffered a near fatal heart attack.


King Graham: “I’m not quite dead yet.” 

 


Leisure Suit Larry Goes Looking for Love (in Several Wrong Places)
Sierra
Released: 1988

The smarmy protagonist still has a gigantic forehead and is still looking to get laid. The sequel slightly played down the sexual content and discarded the dating sim-like gameplay in favor of a more linear design, disappointing many pre-pubescent gamers looking for hot pixelated action.


Above: The game begins with Larry mowing the lawn of the woman he lusted after in the finale of the original. Unfortunately, she can’t remember who he is 

 


Police Quest II: The Vengeance
Sierra
Released: 1988

Police Quest II put you back in the role of Sonny Bonds. This time, we found our hero once again in pursuit of the drug dealer Jessie Bains, who has escaped prison and plans to extract his revenge on everyone involved with his capture in the original. The sequel also featured a little more gunplay, but as always, the focus is on good detective work and following the proper procedures.

 


Tangent: Having a gun is one of the coolest things about being a cop


 
32 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
Starplatinum  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Nice trip through memory lane. Almost makes me want to play through Monkey Island again. Great article but needs more Gabriel Knight!
Starplatinum  - 6 months 5 days ago 
That was a great trip through memory lane! Makes me wanna play Monkey Island 1 & 2 again. Great feature but wish there was more on Gabriel Knight!
Wizrai  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Monkey...island?
AshLynx  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Monkey Island! Some of the greatest and most hilarious and clever games ever made! If this is three, what is this? (in-joke)
DagDabreemie  - 6 months 5 days ago 
How come the Fable and Fiends Legend of Kyrandia trilogy by Virgin Interactive / Westwood Studios never got a mention as great graphic adventure games by their own right of merit in these articles? Didn't anyone else play these?
FinalGamer  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Is there a part 3 coming up at all or is this decided here and now?
Because I just love seeing The DIG mentioned, dammit it's my fave point-click game ever.
atomgrad  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Wow, thanks Tyler! I feel all warm and fuzzy inside when I think of these old games.
Denrok  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Meh, Cyan will always be top for me when it comes to adventure games.
Kattleox  - 6 months 5 days ago 
Well, I was raised on Kings Quest and Space Quest, so Sierra will always have a place in my heart, despite my love of Monkey Island.
usmovers_02  - 6 months 5 days ago 
It's Myst or bust for me. I wasn't a gamer in the 80's and was only just starting in the 90's.

When it comes to adventure games, I've gotta have at LEAST the graphic quality of Myst. I just can't do old games anymore (except for you Prince of Persia! You'll always be #1!)

reCAPTCHA: who outlines (not me)
pj6159  - 6 months 5 days ago 
The only adventure game I remember playing, Freddy Pharkas: Frontier Pharmacist, by Sierra, isn't even mentioned in the article!
RedOutlive10  - 6 months 4 days ago 
I remember Grim Fandango, story and characters. That game was so awesome... Remake pretty please? Or maybe another adventure game with the same flavor.
435  - 6 months 4 days ago 
Neglect for the Laura Bow adventures saddens me, Mr. Nagata.
Sandman89  - 6 months 4 days ago 
Great article and all, but i hate how you covered the Lucas arts golden years of Lucas arts (Day of the Tentacle, Full throttle, Grim fandango etc) in a small paragraph.... unless theres a part 3?
Sandman89  - 6 months 4 days ago 
Shit...typo :-p
cookie23q  - 6 months 4 days ago 
lucasarts ftw
Vagrant  - 6 months 4 days ago 
As Sandman89 said...It looks like this was rushed.

But yar. I think MI and Grim Fandango alone mean Lucasarts win.
JohnnyMaverik  - 6 months 4 days ago 
Lol, just cuz of this im now guna go hunt down my copy of Monkey Island 1, 2 and maybe even 3 nd re-install, try nd find a way to make em work on vista, and play the best adventure games ever. Monky Island was actually my first game which i picked up when i was six, nd i still blame it and Toomb Raider 1 & 2 for making me a gaming nut.
Red  - 6 months 4 days ago 
I remember King's Quest VI came packaged with my dad's new--at the time--PC. I must have been too young to enjoy it because I had no idea what to do about a quarter of the way into it.
GamesRadarTylerNagata  - 6 months 4 days ago 
Yes, I would've liked more time to work on this whole thing. I had plans to include a section to fan-made tributes with adventure games and art, as well as more fun facts and pull quotes from past interviews with the designers from both companies that I had collected. Besides leaving out a few major adventures from both companies, it also overlooks many great re-releases and collection editions.
Related Games
PC
PC