Quantcast

Game censorship around the world

The state of state-imposed babysitting

Words: Tyler Wilde, GamesRadar US

Games are banned in two primary ways. The first is by corporate policy. When a company refuses to sell or distribute an unrated game, it is effectively censoring the game, but they can’t be entirely lampooned for attempting to maintain a positive image. Nintendo has every right to prevent “Sextrobes: Pornigins” from being released on Wii.

The second way games are banned involves direct or indirect interference from governments, and this is what makes us rage. In certain countries, state-imposed censorship is undisputedly the norm, and in others it’s bordering. We’re focusing primarily on this type of censorship, the kind that furrows our freedom-of-expression-loving eyebrows, as we embark on a delightful tour of creative oppression around the world.


The United Kingdom


PEGI (Pan European Game Information) is fair enough with its ratings, and UK authorities do not ban games as a policy. The most recent controversy involved Manhunt 2, though Rockstar’s murder-fest caused a stir everywhere. The British Board of Film Classification rejected the game, and its sale became illegal. David Cooke, director of the BBFC, commented, “There is sustained and cumulative casual sadism in the way in which these killings are committed.” But with some fairly significant edits (which were also required in the US and elsewhere), the game was eventually released in the UK. The only other controversy in recent memory involved Carmageddon. In order to be released, the game’s hapless pedestrians were replaced with robots, but after an appeal the game was released with its originally intended bloodiness intact.


Above: Carmageddon’s mess of bloody pixels was initially too much in the UK 


The United States of America


Like the UK, the US has no significant “ban list” for games. Most game censorship in the US is self-censorship by companies which desire positive public perception. For example, when Manhunt 2 received an Adults Only rating, it was not legally banned from sale in the US, but neither Sony nor Nintendo would allow it to be published, and GameStop wouldn’t have carried it as policy.


Above: Family fun on Wii! 

Likewise, many games out of Japan, especially during the NES and SNES eras, were stripped of blood and nudity to appeal to what was perceived as a more conservative American audience.


Above: “Oh god, a puddle of blood!  Those sensitive pacifists in America won’t have this! What’s that? They were the ones who dropped the…? Oh, right. Look, the guys at NOA say to take it out.” 

Citizens of the US do have to worry about overzealous, self-righteous “family values” groups who treat media as if it’s a disease to be cured, and seek to strip responsibility away from consumers and legislate babysitting. The Mass Effect “Sexbox scandal” is indicative of the kind of ignorant bullshit these pricks are capable of pulling – vilifying a game because it has a tasteful sex scene which would have barely pushed a film from PG-13 to R.


Above: Oh the horror! Kids who shouldn’t even be playing this game might start to think that sex between consenting adults is natural! And one of them is blue! Interracial sex even! 


Japan


Games are rarely censored in Japan, with the exception of some pornographic censorship, which relates more to other laws than it does videogames. The Computer Entertainment Rating Organization (CERO) rates most games in Japan, and tends to hand out games lower (less mature) ratings than Western ratings boards. The Ethics Organization of Computer Software (EOCS) also rates games in Japan, with a focus on PC games of a sexy, sexy nature.


Above: Ah, good old Artificial Girl 2... classic 


 
60 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
Theonik  - 1 month 23 days ago 
lol, there are still arcades here in Greece. So the law was barely enforced (I hadn't even heard of the law before reading it in the Guinness book of records). Nice article btw.
Oh and i guess i'm first.
Cyberninja  - 1 month 23 days ago 
thank god i wasnt born in any of those places on the last page but i think i am going to learn japanese so i can import the games that are not in the us.
D4rk2triker  - 1 month 23 days ago 
I read somewhere that Pokemon Blue version was banned in Saudi Arabia for having "Jewish imagery". wtf?
husk94  - 1 month 23 days ago 
@D4rk2triker, yes it was banned for having the star of david
Samael  - 1 month 23 days ago 
If it wasn't for kangaroos, didgeridoos and Steve Irwin, Australia would totally suck.
poiman  - 1 month 23 days ago 
that whole mass effect situation was overblown. im sure if kids wanted to see alien sex they'd go on something called google
CatrParrot  - 1 month 23 days ago 
I had a feeling that (the ironically NOT sexy) Sexy Poker would be in this article.
Pr0fesserCha0s  - 1 month 23 days ago 
Wow thank god i live in Bahrain
iKOemos  - 1 month 23 days ago 
It's because of Australia us Kiwis got the watered down version of GTAIV. At least the ban got lifted when someone took the game to the PEGI and they said "this owns!". See Australia, our Government is cool.
cart00n  - 1 month 23 days ago 
Let's just hope Ahnuld's Law gets thrown out of the supreme court...
gangrenous  - 1 month 23 days ago 
As an Aussie by birth I felt I had to sign up and stand up for the traditions of this great count... SCREW IT! this backwards little hick town of a Nation can't seem to get it's head around the fact that Video games are not just for children, the last government was so conservative that it felt Pong was subversive and the current one just has no idea about this stuff. I'm moving to Wales, at least they have leeks
CountFenring  - 1 month 22 days ago 
Germany is weird, I went there over the summer. While there I went to the mall. Everything was casual games in the console section, and the PS2 area was huge.

Did anyone else hear about the GRAW 2 being banned in Chihuahua, Mexico? I think it happened... Does anyone else remember this?
Amnesiac  - 1 month 22 days ago 
People's Republic of China. Infringement on others' legitimate rights.

People have legitimate rights in China!?
idlemindkiller  - 1 month 22 days ago 
great read. I cant stand this type of censorship. Just let us big boys/girls play our games!! On an unrelated note. Tyler Kudos to the OXM Zombie special issue. Please tell me theres more kick ass stuff like this in the works.
GamerTagsSuck  - 1 month 22 days ago 
Australia? Really? Why would they be so strict? Look at America. They've almost never banned a videogame and only 45% of their population is serial killers.
AIDSWIDGET  - 1 month 22 days ago 
Yes in china you have a legitimate right to work from the age of 4 and a legitimate right to umm well uhh freedom of uhh umm things.
Mao(er) Power!
Scott1121  - 1 month 22 days ago 
If 45% of our population is serial killers and serial killers are people who kill more than one person shouldn't almost everyone be dead. With the exception of the serial killers of course. I said kill way too much in that comment lol.
Pakatari  - 1 month 22 days ago 
Ok, so the artcle? Great. Cencorship everywhere? Just plane fucking retarted. Lets start with the fact that videogames, do not in many ways, encourage violence, wild sex, and use of drugs. Nutjobs, and parents who cant tell their children the difference between real life and video games are the problem. And the fact that cencorship everywhere shows the fact that everyone wants somone to blame. If a man bombs a building, European Leaders are always happy theres a brand new game bein released to take the fall. Christ... human beings are getting more pathetic everyday... I feel bad for the next generation XD
FriendlyFire  - 1 month 22 days ago 
I'm so glad to live in Canada for this. Not a single banned game, which, for a change, pictures Canada as a rather open and progressive country.

Let's just hope this doesn't change...
Valntyne  - 1 month 22 days ago 
Wait, C&C Tiberium Wars came out?
Related Games
Gears of War
Xbox 360
Manhunt 2
PS2
Manhunt 2
Wii
Gears of War 2
Xbox 360
Left 4 Dead 2
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Manhunt 2
PSP
Gamecube
GameCube
We've got 1,000 MAG beta keys - want one? N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
King's Bounty: Armoured Princess Now Available N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Fallout 3 Avatar Items  N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Aion Update Released N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
UPDATE: Heavy Rain Features A Male Shower Scene N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009