Quantcast

Death Race 2009

E3 09: Forza 3 vs Need For Speed SHIFT

Words: Chris Antista, GamesRadar US



Release Date: September 22nd

The NFS series takes a turn for the hardcore with a renewed focus on what it’s like to be a driver, and not necessarily of a Nissan.

PRESS RELEASE PROMISES


-65 realistically unique cars spanning the last 35 years
-In-Car view returns to NFS for the first time in nearly a decade
-50 unique layouts across 18 tracks
-First game to “True Driver’s Experience”
-Numerous mid-race, objective-based incentives


NOTABLE NEWNESS


Well, the emphasis on the Driver Experience could be the game’s crown jewel. But of similar importance, I’ve been dying to see what exactly the devs had meant by the promise of mid race “milestones,” or the achievable goals beyond simply pole position. After all, most traditional racers are kind of like our Comments section: It’s all about being “first!!!” and little else. One of the greatest strides EA has taken to distance itself from ordinary racing game is eliminating the need to quit every time you clumsily plummet to last place with a brand new points-based reward system.

 

Points are basically put towards your overall profile XP (applicable online and off) and are broken into two categories: Precision and Aggression. The former rewards stuff like immaculately drifting around corners and emerging through course sections unscathed, while the latter encourages you to trade a little paint.

But mind where you channel that aggression, Mr. Wheeler. As boring and deceitful as most promises of driver AI get, SHIFT’s non-playable drivers have are looking to kick the tired tradition of rubberband bullshit. It’s true that AI drivers won’t swipe you off the track as if you were invisible while trying to realign themselves to a poorly designed carousel. But better still, they can develop personal vendettas against you if they perceive you to be an aggro-asshole.

 

Leave them alone, they’ll leave you alone… but hit them, and they’ll hit you back. Whether specific NPCs are born pricks or you simply have to teach them remains to be seen, but since the creators are referring to the dynamic system as “emotions,” one could assume that you could start out a race against the occasional enemy with a personality disorder.  


TEST DRIVE


I was floored when I first laid eyes on SHIFT last March, although not necessarily in a good way. It was a little unsettling to be informed that a series I’ve comfortably come to know for hot pursuits, open-world maps, and neon body kits was about to go the Forza route of real-world tracks and precision handling and physics. (Even more so, when you consider the last game starred an undercover cop who had to overthrow a crime syndicate using only his Porsche.) 

But after playing it again on the show floor, I’m happy to report this mature-minded departure is shaping into the NFS series’ most significant evolution in years. Perhaps ever. While it’s without a doubt more realistic than any Need For Speed in years, I caution you folks not to write the game off as a boring simulator. “The True Driver Experience.” Certainly sounds like PR babble… yet, it’s actually something fresh, innovative and downright arcadey.

Modern racers have all but forgotten there’s an actual person behind the wheel, but SHIFT’s gonna make damn sure you remember. Not only will you find your hands interacting with all facets of automotive minutia, but the cockpit view quite gorgeously displays a living, breathing human reacting to the road with every bit of detail as your vehicle. Haphazardly pinballing yourself around courses results in disorienting onscreen concussion effect that varies depending on the brutality of your impact.


PARTING THOUGHTS


As apprehensive as I was over Need For Speed: SHIFT’s change of pace, the developers behind Skate and the critically lauded GTR series have made me a believer again. If you played ProStreet and Undercover just long enough to be underwhelmed, you’re going to see this as a vast improvement. The driver experience is no bullshit, and although I could care less about customizing my interior, watching stuff like your drivers neck crane back at high accelerations and feeling the force of an impact on your skull is both subtly sublime and jarringly immersive.

 

I love an on-track guideline, but it’s the concussion elements will make you a better driver. Momentary blindness is far more of an incentive to master courses than any dented fender could ever hope to be. The same could be said for the point/reward system, even though they’re basically Project Gotham’s Kudos points. But it’s not like you’ll be getting anything like that this year…


WHO WINS?


Right when I was getting over the shock of NFS and Forza actually being comparable, I received another kick jolt once I realized I was actually more excited for SHIFT, which quite simply looks way better in terms of next-gen presentation. Visually speaking, SHIFT actually looks prettier, all the while offering significantly enhanced gameplay from its last title (Thank God).  Sure, its scope is significantly smaller, and you know it won’t have a fraction of the community and DLC support as Forza, but all the upgrades feel infinitely more substantial.

If I had to pick a winner - and I do - I’d go with SHIFT. It looks a little more fresh and exciting, while Forza looks like hours more of the beautiful same (but what a value!) Fortunately for me, by the time I finish SHIFT, EA will doubtlessly be hyping its next NFS title AND I won’t head into Forza 3 unprepared!

Never did I ever conceive of a day when an annual Need for Speed game would rival my interest in a new Forza… but here we are. Feel free to call me an asshole in the comments.

Jun 18, 2009


 
48 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
skittles360X  - 5 months 5 days ago 
Don't care much for sim racing games but might have to check these out.

(also first. can't resist)
lava_lamp  - 5 months 5 days ago 
perfect article for us racists
chrisat928  - 5 months 5 days ago 
Uh-oh.

Time for Mr. Anitsta to get ripped.
imadejoolaff  - 5 months 5 days ago 
SHIFT is going to be a great game, by the looks and hands-on. It will be nice to have a realistic racing game since GT5:P dropped the ball hardcore.
nik41507  - 5 months 5 days ago 
5TH!!!!!!!

leaning on Foraza 3. Need for spped has gone down the tubes lately
435  - 5 months 5 days ago 
Mmm. Car porn.

I'm being forced by friends to pick up Forza. Being a Burnout man myself, it's a tough sell, but I think the HKs and Walthers pointed towards me make the purchase a little easier to stomach.

Can you guys put those away? Please?

reCAPCHA: packard Bell
nik41507  - 5 months 5 days ago 
- Comment removed by Moderator
Reported
nik41507  - 5 months 5 days ago 
dear 435



GO BURNOUT
BURNOT PARIDISE OWNS
reCAPTACHA:as triggest
srky13  - 5 months 5 days ago 
lol theres comments that say 11 months ago


reCAPTCHA: 59.9 proposes
curly_jefferson  - 5 months 5 days ago 
Frankly Mr Antista i couldn't disagree with your article more and i think that Mario Karty will be the greatest racing sim EEEvar. oh the unfunniness of it all, Yeah NFS looks really nice
Frostyman  - 5 months 5 days ago 
Why buy just one when you can buy both?

Unless, of course you're po...in a difficult financial situation?

They both look great, although personally, im not so crazy about the whole "Move with the Car" aspect of SHIFT. Plus Forza does have about...what is it, 350 more cars than Shift?

But I'll still buy both, because they both look awesome.
LittleTaco  - 5 months 5 days ago 
man i wish i got a "your grape" sticker LOL
GamesRadarChrisAntista  - 5 months 5 days ago 
@Frosty

According to the news, the entire universe is in a difficult financial situations! I wouldn't know... I write about games for a living ($$!)

Though, you bring up good point, Frosty. The first talking point of Forza 3 in press releases, net forums and conversation is usually "400 CARS!!!"

Thing is, I believe there's probably around 10 players who would use them ALL in any meaningful way. And if you're tinkering and tuning as both games allow, you're probably using less than 10.

It's great in terms of choice, but a new coat of paint doesn't mean all that much if the experience hasn't evolved.
Ninja-KiLLR  - 5 months 5 days ago 
im suprised GT5 didnt get thrown in on the melee
michaelmcc827  - 5 months 5 days ago 
I really can't believe no one's said this yet, but NFS Shift looks way way way too much like Grid to me. (Grid also had rewind feature). For this I'll prob pick up forza, even though I'm a die-hard NFS fan. I've already played GRID, I don't need to again. It was great though...

great article btw. and gt5 wasn't in the mix cause it wasnt at e3, and won't be released in our lifetime.

recaptcha: great thoughts ...indeed
MechGyver  - 5 months 5 days ago 
Need For Speed Shit....lol...anyone...?

But seriosly where´s the hot model/actress for this game? I´ve only seen cars and tracks till now, this ought to be a bad sign for NFS
iluvmyDS  - 5 months 5 days ago 
I've always batted an eye at Forza, as far as the customization. I blow at car sims though.
TheMonarch  - 5 months 5 days ago 
For me I'm looking forward to Forza. One thing Chris didn't mention was the video editor. @$$hole : D I could totally see making a sweet video of rollevers when I eventually push my car way beyond it's limits.
TURbo  - 5 months 5 days ago 
The Need For Speed series does a lot of add one feature here and get rid of another feature there. It is nice that you can have a driver's view, since Underground you could only see the outside. Need For Speed Carbon, Pro Street, and Undercover have been disappointing, but this does look really cool.
GearsofRabies  - 5 months 5 days ago 
I'm sold on SHIFT. The footage they showed at ea's e3 conference with the cockpit view blew me away. I became immersed in a choppy streaming video. It has to be good if it can do that.
Related Games
Tekken 6 getting patched up for Thanksgiving N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 24, 2009
LEGO Indiana Jones 2 Will Continue Adventure With... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 24, 2009
When Turkey's Attack.. N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 24, 2009
Mass Effect 2 Surprise Coming Tomorrow w/ New... N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 24, 2009
PS3 & LBP Promote Education with $2 Million... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 24, 2009