Quantcast

Are games more violent today?

See history's most brutal pastimes from gladiatorial games to medieval massacres for the answer

Words: Tyler Nagata, GamesRadar US

Dec 27, 2007

"No longer are games simply about shooting aliens and destroying asteroids, but instead the top selling games reward players for killing police officers, maiming elderly persons, running over pedestrians and committing despicable acts of murder and torture upon women and racial minorities," says California State Senator, Leland Yee in an opinion piece on his website.

It's still a popular stance for politicians and strangers to videogames to take - this idea that gory games like Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas or Manhunt 2 signify the impending apocalypse. With such alarmist and over exaggerated claims, you'd think we all have a new generation of murder crazy sadists that love torturing seniors and minorities to look forward to. It's true that violent acts in today's games look more realistic than ever; pressing a chainsaw deeper into your friend's brain in Gears of War is a far cry from the peaceful paddles of Pong. But are games and the ways we choose to entertain ourselves really any more violent today?

Read on for a look at history's most violent games, the ones where losing might've meant a very real and painful death. These are the brutal pastimes that people entertained themselves with long before Death Race 2000 or Doom stirred up concerns over excessively violent content in the videogames. You might be surprised.

Above: This Fatality isn't so shocking when compared to this sculpture of Perseus holding Medusa's head. There's plenty of gore in Greek literature and their games

The Game: Pugilism
Developer: The Greeks
Release date: 688 BC
Genre: Fighting
Number of players: 2
Rating: Rated M for death by beat downs, bleeding, and full frontal nudity.

People have probably gotten a kick out of watching two guys beat each other to a bloody pulp for as long as we've existed on this lonely little planet. Egyptian wall carvings suggest that boxing may have been practiced since 3000 BC. But most of our knowledge on ancient fist fighting comes from the Greeks, who called it pugilism.

What made the Greek sport more brutal than its modern day equivalent? There were no time limits or rounds for one. Lengthy fights were settled with the contestants taking turns pounding each other with free hits (Flintstones-style) until one man finally fell. Also, instead of padded gloves, fighters wrapped their hands in tough leather strips sprinkled with a dash of metal. This ensured that combatants would give each other a generous amount of cuts throughout the fight, making for a bloody battle. Although deaths were rare, records do indicate that fighters sometimes died.

If that weren't enough, ancient boxers also brawled in the nude. Was a pair of trunks too much to ask for back then? The idea of a huge naked guy trying to force feed us a knuckle sandwich with his dong dangling about wildly just makes us want to cross our legs, curl up in the fetal position, and pretend we're somewhere else.


 
33 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
barrage7667  - 1 year 1 month ago 
- Comment removed by Community
Reported
Valandil  - 1 year 1 month ago 
2nd! Yay!
Ravenbom  - 1 year 1 month ago 
I find it surprising that a game where 11 steroid pumped beef-castles are facing off against another 11 raging shrunken testicle/bacne (back acne) meat mountains who all want to kill each other and only wear flimsy vinyl tunics and plastic plates on their shoulders isn't seen as violent, even after 20 years of Madden.
Yet you kill one little hooker to get back your money, and GTA3 stirs up controversy.
oryandymackie  - 1 year 1 month ago 
I'm sick of government and co. saying that, oh, we ca't play this. It's fiction. Definition of fiction. Imaginary. Unrealistic. I play horrors but I don't want to carve up people like Christmas dinner with a chainsaw.
Scott1121  - 1 year 1 month ago 
5th woohoo
nadrewod999  - 11 months 3 days ago 
Ravenbom and oryandymackie, I totally agree. I bet that if thos IDIOTS who say video gams ar mor dangrous than guns and narcotics (plus are even spending $90 million dollars in a financial crisis to prove it, even though there has never EVER been a case where someone is killed directly by a videogame's influence since most killers wre crazy to begin with and anything could have set him off) don't even realize that they are both the cause of millions of dollars of debt and that, if they jst let the nsdtrythrve, we wil haveagreat stock market, whch couldeaslyhel stmlate thsecny and actually et thes guysget a real jobtat tey can actally do (coughBurgerKingburgerflippercough) instead of taking away both our freedom as gamers to buy whatever we want with just cash (because, after all, most great games have a high rating, am I right?) and our money as a country to keep us from going in "The Great Depression 2: This Time It's Personal" (ok, I will admit that games have some ifluence on my life, BUT I WILL NOT LET A FEW HILLBILLIES WITH FAKE DEGREES SAY THAT THEY HAVE FOUND STUDIES THAT SHOW THAT ALL GAMES ARE BAD, EVEN THOUGH THEY OVIOUSLY AVOID EDUCATIONAL CHILDREN GAMES, jut like us).
Cwf2008  - 11 months 2 days ago 
I dunno but i have more than once thought of one of those damn idiot politicians who never played a game in their life and think games are evil...what was i saying? Oh ya i have several times imagined them getting eating my alligators or dying in horrific ways...but video games didnt do that it was just hatred of them
CoD_22  - 11 months 2 days ago 
you would have to be pretty insane in the first place to kill someone because of playing gta. you play games because you can do things you wouldnt normally do in real life.
El_Hombre11  - 11 months 1 day ago 
the Gov. just needs to get it in their minds that Video Games are simplistic in the same way as movies, people watch/play them to ESCAPE REALITY. You watch Wanted, Lord of the Rings, the Matrix, Batman, or SisterHood of the Traveling pants kauz you want to know WHAT IT WOULD BE LIKE if it were real. Some people play Madden kauz they love football and maybe, huh, would actually want to have the unnatural ability to control some of their favorite players. Imagine that!!!
Games weren't made to duplicate reality and breed a bunch of cyberkillers, thats what the internet is for
Games were made to replace reality with anything we want at the time
Corsair89  - 11 months 14 hours ago 
Yeesh, some of the Manhunt 2 kills made me cringe. Brutal.
Corsair89  - 11 months 14 hours ago 
Yeesh, some of the Manhunt 2 kills made me cringe. Brutal.
Corsair89  - 11 months 14 hours ago 
damn, double post
TrigunGunner  - 10 months 26 days ago 
I hate how the politicians and all these government big shots go yacking about how bad games are how violent and mature they are, yet other forms of media like movies and books get none of that criticism
Smiffy99  - 10 months 23 days ago 
Okay um...one, two,...uh, 14th! Woo! I'm really on top of it!
Smiffy99  - 10 months 23 days ago 
Okay um...one, two,...uh, 14th! Woo! I'm really on top of it!
adrenaguy  - 10 months 18 days ago 
yeah I'm sorry but it's like how they said that mass effect was a "sex simulator" well i have found plenty of them on the we doing that and ONLY that, and , as you said, el_hombre 11 the government should see films like that and realise, hey, this is just as bad! in fact, it'snot bad at all, neither are. because it's FICTION. as in the "it's not real but we like it because it's something we couldn't do" it's like when i go on rollercoaster sims, i build totally insane roller coasters and ride them just to see what it would be like to ride it, doesnt mean i'm gonna go build a coaster that creates Gs up to 45 now am I? no. that's just plain stupid. and impossible. so stop bugging us government and tbh, take it like a man and realise that it's not the gamers who kill people, it's the kids with bad parenting etc. they are the criminals, the robbers, the murderers, you get the Gist, get all the money put into "proving"(getting a load of criminals and asking if they play video games) that games are at fault and put it into helping those who are having trouble with their lives, help parents, help schools, and most importantl, help the criminals. b***h.
Darkdraak21  - 10 months 13 days ago 
The govt. just wants to find something to blame thats simple like video games or movies or music. I'm sorry but if kids are so screwed up these days that they do stuff thats in video games then its the parents fault. Also if a kid kills somebody or if someone kills somebody and they have a past as a gamer that person says that it was the video games just to get there arse out of trouble and sue some big game companies for a million bucks.
StevenHawking  - 10 months 12 days ago 
Okay, I want to play manhunt 2 now. That, and I want to see some good gladiator games now.... Someone should call Rockstar and say, "Make me a brutally horrific gladiator fighting game, and we'll call it historical license."
cdell  - 9 months 29 days ago 
this article is completely true. i hope Tyler that you dont mind me quoteing it (with citations)in a paper im writing for L.A. class.
doomdoomdoom  - 9 months 26 days ago 
All that money to prove games are evil could have gone to stopping real criminals or creating more or bigger prisons.

I AM HUNGRY FOR MY RIGHTS TO PLAY VIDEO GAME!!!
ARE YOU WITH ME?
Related Games
PC
PC
PSP
PSP
Xbox 360
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Gamecube
GameCube
PC
PC
PSP
PSP
Xbox 360
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Gamecube
GameCube
Nintendo Download - Wii and DSi Shop releases for... N4G
Wii News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Original A Boy and His Blob Now Available on... N4G
Wii News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Big Screen Drake's Fortune Lands Screenwriter Duo N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
Dante's Inferno may get DLC, producer wants a... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009
By Popular Demand: MAG Beta Extended N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 23, 2009