13 Worst gaming innovations of all time

From gameplay mechanics to design flaws - these are the most heinous offenders of gaming

Words: Shane Patterson, GamesRadar US

Peripherals

Why developers thought they would rock:
Sometimes a normal controller just won’t cut it. There’s no better way to be immersed in a game than specifically designed plastic fun gear. Guitar Hero, DDR, and hell, even Duck Hunt proved that if you have a replica of some instrument to interact with, then the gap between gamer and joy is easily bridged.

Why they suck:
It’s hard to look cool when your apartment/dorm/bedroom is filled with Fisher-Price game accessories. To non-gamers, it looks like you collect toy replicas based on fantasies you had when you were six; like being a rock god or driving a car. It would be sad if it weren’t so damn accurate today - just replace make-believe with Rock Band.

In fact, we wonder why your tragic mess replicates mundane activities. For every Gibson guitar or GunCon, there’s a DDR dance mat, steering wheel or fishing controller set to embarrass your parents. We dare you to get laid with even a regular controller protruding from your TV, let alone those USB conga drums lying in day-old Panda Express boxes.

If you’re not ten years-old or at least a young parent, do yourself a favor and hide that shit in the closet.

Bullet time

Why developers thought it would rock:
You know the drill - fill a meter, slow down time and leap through the air annihilating as many baddies as possible before the meter expires. When Max Payne did it in 2001, it was fresh, exciting and made you feel like a badass against crazy-impossible odds.

Why it sucks:
You can’t play a game nowadays without slowing time to pull off some outlandish feat of agility, strength or steady aim. What was once an exciting new feature has become the new double-jump - a gameplay mechanic that developers rely on like a crutch. Rather than designing blood-pumping fair fights, games are now structured to highlight how aggressive enemies are. There’s no possible way you’re gonna ice thirty armed superguards with dual Uzis, unless you cheat your way through like some sort of temporal magician.

Moreover time-slowing seems like the only way to make old franchises seem relevant and hip (WWE SmackDown!, Spyro the Dragon, Tony Hawk, Burnout) or new titles feel distressingly old and outdated riding the extreme wave (TimeShift, Stranglehold, Resistance: Fall of Man). Remember, slow-motion shit is still shit.

The most mediocre box art
PS2 Feature
Jul 24, 2008
E3 Close Standing
360 Feature
Jul 23, 2008
E3 08: The videos you may have missed
360 Feature
Jul 23, 2008
The 100 lamest game-industry clichés
PS3 Feature
Jul 22, 2008
'Alpha Protocol' Will Have Plenty Of Sex Scenes,... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Jul 24, 2008
Metal Gear Solid 4 New rumor: Another New final? N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Jul 24, 2008
Siren Scares PS3s N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Jul 24, 2008
Spore E-Card Creator Announced: Share Your Spore... N4G
PC News from N4G
Jul 24, 2008
Kojima to attend Metal Gear Online Tournament at... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Jul 24, 2008