Quantcast

13 Worst gaming innovations of all time

From gameplay mechanics to design flaws - these are the most heinous offenders of gaming

Words: Shane Patterson, GamesRadar US
« Back to Article

 
42 Comments
Order Comments: Newest First | Oldest First
theguru  - 9 months 10 days ago 
is it just me or do al lthe people at GR hate 3-D?

It's not that 3-D has ruined games with the glitches like you list here (using halo 2 as an example is, lets face it, a little stupid. That was probably the most glitchy Bungie ever). Its just there are extra dimensions for it to go wrong with. For example, there isn't a 'right' or 'left' in a 2-D game!!!
midgiemelendez  - 6 months 19 days ago 
whoa, yall totally went overkill

p.s. escort missions suck, itd be awesome if we could decide to just kill em as a choice :p
euanb102  - 6 months 19 days ago 
escort missions are the apex of stupidity. Either the thing your supposed to be protecting says "Dont worry i'll be fine" , runs out into enemy gunfire and then becomes a bullet holder or he gets stuck behind a box and you have to save him from his own mental inadequecy OR he lags behind you and it takes hours for him to slowly plod back to the most recent checkpoint. NOBODY LIKES TO ESCORT OTHER PEOPLE!
euanb102  - 6 months 19 days ago 
I rather like 3D I think the GR editors just don't like it cus their a bunch of old men who liked gaming back in the old days when characters were square and the third dimension was something only heard about on an episode of The Twilight Zone.
killemall  - 6 months 18 days ago 
I have to agree that swimming in vidgames is infact, lame. It asooks, except for in Ecco which was alot of fun but that's just not the same is it.
What about excess ladder climbing? no takers there?

i do hate escort missions as well, especially when the ai person is to stupid to hide in the room but runs all the way back to the starting point if not satisfied with the amount of protection offered. And although Ico is critically acclaimed... can we say giant escort mission of doom?

One last thing i hate that has improved 10x in the past couple of years but still isn't quite right? stormtrooper aim. Great for my enemies wrong for my allies to have.
TripleAD  - 6 months 16 days ago 
For destructable environments red faction guerella does a good job at it
mikedaquilam  - 4 months 27 days ago 
windwaker was fun!
i hate escorts too.
nice job, neofile!
walrusthewill  - 4 months 5 days ago 
well not all of these are bad, it just takes a good developer to perfect the innovation in such a beautiful way that it makes up for all the sucky games that tries and failed at it, like red faction for destructable environments
barrage7667  - 4 months 5 days ago 
no bad AI is teh worst ive beaten an area of the game because i stood on a platform and all the enemies ran at me and fell to their deaths WTF???
aberkromby  - 4 months 5 days ago 
tealth missions are terrible, except when you have the option to "Rambo in" if you really want to, like in ssassins creed and socom.
marioman523  - 4 months 4 days ago 
I agree with the bit about swimming, but it's not enough reason to put the game up on the shelf for the rest eterninty, un-played.
Schlehuber  - 4 months 4 days ago 
I just want to point out the one exception to the swimming thing - Majora's Mask, while wearing the Zora Mask.

Like a dolphin, but one that can shoot lightning and walk on the bottom while fighting kung-fu style.
Awesome.
abrock123  - 4 months 4 days ago 
hey neofile don't like leveling play oblivion or fallout it scales the enemies so that there always the same difficulty
JohnEP  - 4 months 2 days ago 
Geez, you missed "Checkpoint saves" or even worse, "x number of lives". So if you are NOT a expert thumb twicher, you get to REPEAT, REPEAT,REPEAT the level, level, level.
How about "unlockable stuff" that I will NEVER see as I cannot click a button fast enough to earn the game developer's respect.
Val24  - 4 months 1 day ago 
In my opinion escort missions are absolutely the worst! After passing HAWX, with about 10 of those, which is a half of all missions that there are, I was so glad im done with it! Because you usually have to ether escort a hugeass plane, which should hae had at least SOME guns on it, well, it doesn't so you have to shoot enemies off while that plane is flying, in the same directon as before, and not even considering hiding somewhere or at least lowering lattitude, but the stupidest thing is when you have to help artilery, then you understand that AI was developed ONLY for enemies, while the guys you're helping are just dummies, shooting in one place, untill they alll die of course, which does happen alot since thaey have no brain...
kodesy  - 4 months 18 hours ago 
I'd say that it's unanimous..everyone hates escort missions, myself included. Defence is horrible too, like in Gears at spots where you have to defend Jack while he opens doors..he's friggin invisible 95% of the time anyways! Why can't he just stay invisible while he opens the door?
yonderTheGreat  - 4 months 7 hours ago 
In defense of "stealth"... you should have added a "do it right or don't do it at all" section like you did for destructible environments. Thief games were incredible (looking fwd to Thief 4), whereas "stealth" games like Splinter Cell befuddle me. Why use "stealth" when you have a danged machine gun?! Ugh...

Anywayz... yeah... stealth works right in the few examples of where they implemented it correctly.
TreyTable  - 3 months 29 days ago 
One thing I really hate in games is poor writing when it comes to text. Found mostly where either the writer is doing a translation piece and he or she edits their own work, which ends up with some questionable language that doesn't make sense in any context, or even when the text is done in one's native language, except they use poor judgment or are trying to sound hip, which just turns out to be tragic.

Some of the things that bother me the most is using a "z" to end a word that really ends with an "S", replacing the word "you" with the letter "u", the constant use of the made up word "alot" in place of "a lot", and/or "noone" instead of "no one."

It's hard to take anybody seriously if their spelling and/or grammar looks like it was written by a retard. I see this everywhere in Internet forums, but when it creeps into games, it is totally unacceptable.
GamingMedley  - 3 months 24 days ago 
I enjoy stealth games. I guess it's just something you gotta have a feel for.
wiiking8  - 3 months 7 days ago 
Stealth can be fun if done right. Now if only developers knew how to do it right.
Related Games
PC
PC
Wii
Wii
PSP
PSP
Xbox 360
Xbox 360
Xbox
Xbox
Gamecube
GameCube
TalkRadar 76 - Actually game related!
360 Feature
Nov 7, 2009
50 iPhone games you need to play
PC Feature
Nov 6, 2009
100 A buttons
Wii Feature
Nov 6, 2009
Characters we wish we knew LESS about
Wii Feature
Nov 5, 2009
Alan Wake Gameplay Video Footage N4G
360 News from N4G
Nov 9, 2009
UT3 mod Prometheus Released for Free N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 9, 2009
Age of Conan Update Released N4G
PC News from N4G
Nov 9, 2009
RPG Deals 11/8 - 11/14 N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 9, 2009
Retail Scoop: New Releases Week of November 10,... N4G
PS3 News from N4G
Nov 9, 2009