Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood review

  • Enormous, landmark-filled world to explore
  • Leonardo's machines are a fun change of pace
  • Uniquely fun multiplayer action
  • Story's kind of flat compared to ACII
  • Visual glitches, occasionally infuriating controls
  • Waiting for the next game after the WTF ending

Cesare’s aided by a handful of prominent sycophants and killers, who – while still being fun to stalk and kill – aren’t as well developed or as interesting as the conspirators of ACII. The only real standouts are Cesare’s sister Lucrezia, who’s portrayed as archly cruel and more than a little unbalanced, and his cousin Juan, a fat, lecherous Cardinal who’s notable mainly for waltzing around in a loincloth when you confront him.

Above: Ew

Oddly enough, most of the charm and character development this time around comes not from Ezio’s storyline, but the other one. You know the one I’m talking about. The one nobody seems to like.

My name is Desmond Miles

If you’ve played previous Creeds, then you already know that the games tend to be split between two narratives: that of Ezio or Altair, and that of their modern-day descendant, Desmond Miles, who’s experiencing their lives through a genome-mining machine called the Animus. As Brotherhood opens, Desmond – who’s on the run from the Templars alongside modern-day Assassins Lucy, Rebecca and Shaun – is brought to a modern version of Monteriggioni, where the team quickly sets up shop.

The good news for Desmond-haters is that, apart from a couple of platforming/puzzle levels at the beginning and end of the game, you never really have to see Desmond at all if you don’t want to. If you do, however, you’re free to leave the Animus at any time from the pause screen, at which point you can explore the town – at night, when nobody’s around, with Desmond’s acrobatic Assassin abilities in full effect.

You can also chat up Desmond’s teammates or (shudder) check his email, which – apart from a couple of late-in-the-game revelations about the other Assassin teams worldwide – doesn’t reveal much aside from what the other characters do in their offscreen time. If you hated checking email in the original, then you’ll be glad to know it can be safely ignored here. If you like the idea of learning a little backstory about the characters, though, it's interesting stuff.

Above: Actual in-game subtitles

What can’t be ignored, however, is what happens after Ezio’s story ends and Desmond’s kicks in again. We won’t spoil it for you, but suffice it to say that there’s a twist cliffhanger at the very end that comes seemingly out of nowhere and left us deeply confused. At this point, we’re looking forward to the sequel just so we can make sense of it.

Also, we should probably warn you not to tense up for any dramatic showdowns between Desmond and the Templars. Instead, you’ll get to play through their Animus-based training program. As them.

Kill your friends

When we first heard about Brotherhood’s idea for multiplayer, it immediately reminded us of The Ship: Murder Party, a 2006 PC game about killing a targeted player while another player hunts for you. While Brotherhood’s concept is similar – you’re tasked with assassinating another player, while some other player (or players) is also hunting you – it’s a bit more complicated than that, not least because of all the onscreen data you’ll have to take in at once.

Each multiplayer match takes place in a medium-sized, town-like map populated not just by other players, but also crowds of civilians who all look just like the player characters. Since you won’t normally be able to detect each other on sight, the key is to try and blend in with the civilians,follow your radar and keep an eye out for anything that might give your intended victim away. (If you see someone running or walking around on a rooftop, for example, that’s a dead giveaway that they’re another player.) Kill the wrong person – or, worse, get killed yourself, or stunned by your intended prey – and you’ll lose your “contract,” and will have to wait to be assigned a new one.

It’s a fantastically challenging setup, and one that can either be extremely rewarding (if your minutes of careful plodding, hiding and misdirection lead to a gruesome kill) or immensely frustrating (if someone else kills you when your kill is within reach). Luckily, you won’t be limited to just feeling your way through crowds blindly; as you level up, you’ll gradually unlock new abilities and perks that range from new weapons (which net you more points when you use them successfully) and faster running to disguises, smoke bombs and Templar Vision, which enables you to instantly spot other players.

Above: This is what happens when you find a stranger in the Alps!

Brotherhood’s multiplayer isn’t just limited to single players hunting each other, either. That mode is called Wanted, and more adventurous players can try Advanced Wanted, which gives you even fewer clues about where your assassination target is. There’s also Alliance, which puts you on a team with another player and tasks you with hunting a second team, while a third team hunts you both; and Manhunt, in which two teams of up to four players take turns hiding from and hunting each other. So long as you’ve got the patience to slowly stalk your kills and gradually level up to the good stuff, multiplayer is definitely one of Brotherhood’s high points.

Is it better than…?

Assassin’s Creed II? No. If it were just a matter of pure gameplay, it would be; Brotherhood brings a raft of improvements and cool add-ons, not the least of which is its multiplayer action. But the things that made ACII so compelling were its story and characters, two areas where Brotherhood falls short. It's not that the story’s hugely disappointing; just that, after the epic narrative of ACII, we really expected more.


Fable III? Yes. Even disregarding complaints about Fable III’s length, Brotherhood’s Rome feels more like a coherent, living world than Fable’s Albion, its fights are more enjoyable and varied, and its action centers around rapidly climbing buildings, something Fable III completely lacks. It also features a whole hell of a lot fewer fetch quests, which is something we can get behind.



Red Dead Redemption? No. While it doesn’t have AC’s free-running or hidden-blade stabbings, Rockstar’s Western epic looks better, is overall more fun, and has a much deeper and more involving story. Brotherhood holds up pretty well next to it, but being an Old West outlaw is still more compelling than being a Renaissance one.  (Also, Brotherhood doesn’t yet have a world-altering, zombie-filled DLC package, and that’s something it might not hurt to remedy.)


Just for you, Metacritic!

While its story falls short of the bar set by Assassin’s Creed II, Brotherhood packs in more than enough new content and improvements to make up for it. It’s not the best of the series, but it’s still an essential piece of the ever-expanding AC puzzle.

Nov 16, 2010

More Info

Release date: Mar 22 2011 - PC
Nov 16 2010 - Xbox 360, PS3 (US)
Nov 19 2010 - Xbox 360, PS3 (UK)
Available Platforms: PC, Xbox 360, PS3
Genre: Action
Published by: Ubisoft
Developed by: Ubisoft
Franchise: Assassin's Creed
ESRB Rating:
Mature: Blood, Sexual Themes, Strong Language, Violence
PEGI Rating:


  • alwaysthere1996 - May 16, 2011 1:37 a.m.

    so super awesome and there is soo much to do... i can play it for hours and never get bored! :)
  • sohaibifikhar - April 21, 2011 6:36 p.m.

    MrCeatherMalone97 is the man... this one's better as in improved for me as compared to AcII minus the character development thing... If AcII's a 9.0 than this is an 8.9...
  • MrCeatherMalone97 - December 13, 2010 9:55 p.m.

    Why did you give it a nine ? Listen to that it's ten out of ten , Would this be better then black ops ?
  • pots555 - December 1, 2010 10:04 p.m.

    This is, for me, the best game of the year. Simply amazing.
  • gamerchick101 - December 1, 2010 7:42 p.m.

    im sorry but am i the only one who hates the ending!?! unless there will be a fourth one, i hope they make one.
  • opeth784 - November 23, 2010 6:09 p.m.

    Amazing dubbed Lebowski reference made me lol hard.
  • kangaroocory - November 20, 2010 12:55 a.m.

    The thing i like most is probably the different outfits instead of the plain ol' white of AC1. Looking forward to a broader color spectrum in the next AC game!
  • Slayer11496 - November 19, 2010 1:48 a.m.

    NON-SPOILER short review for Assassins Creed: Brotherhood I just finished the game and I must say it is awesome.It is nice to see that Ezio's character actually evolve through the two stories. Resurrecting the brotherhood is cool for fans, and strangely fulfilling. Rome is a great landscape that I truly enjoyed playing. Renovating shops is good to the player and is not as repetitive as implied in the Super Review. The combat seems to have gotten a huge overhaul. Players can now use hidden pistol with your sword, and can do quick(and entirely badass) kill streaks. On to Assassins Creed new multiplayer. I have played about five hours in this surprisingly addictive addition. Players new to the game prepare to be molested because this is an in depth, hardcore, multiplayer that requires a full understanding of the game. I have spent a lot of time in the first two games so I am doing pretty well. My favorite game mode is wanted(I think that's what it's called). This mode involves you hunting another player in a sea of look-alike AI's, but the twist is that most of the time you will have someone hunting you too. When I was dominating this one match I had three other players racing to kill me, and as expected it made life difficult at the top. On a scale of one to ten I give this a 9.5 because it delivers in every way a fan can hope for and the only thing that's missing is a 3 at the end of it's name. -John Alvarado
  • Coolbeans69 - November 19, 2010 12:59 a.m.

    Am I the only one who finds Red Dead a little overrated?
  • Deutero - November 18, 2010 8:37 p.m.

    Great review thanks Mr Reparaz. Its good to know that i should lower my expectations for the story and focus more on its other offerings
  • quincytheodore - November 18, 2010 1:08 p.m.

    It's barely a year since I hunted those feathers, they are fast and the quality seems good. I'll definitely try this out. Assassin's Creed is one of those game that really worth you buck.
  • Spybreak8 - November 18, 2010 2:27 a.m.

    I know you have to find games to compare with this one but Fable III and AC:B seem to be very different. It's almost like comparing Burnout and Forza just because they're racing games. Annnyway, good to hear this is good but not better than AC2 per see. Glad I grabbed NFSHP but I plain on grabbing this once I finish AC2. Thanks Mikel for not spoiling AC2 for me, much appreciated.
  • dontshootthereviewer - November 18, 2010 2:01 a.m.

    ok now i gotta get black ops, fallout new vegas and this! way to put out big games so soon guys.
  • philipshaw - November 17, 2010 7:41 p.m.

    This looks awesome but I'm waiting until Christmas to getting it
  • benjman - November 17, 2010 6:50 p.m.

    If you need a new PS3 to play this on go here: I got a ps3 160gb with 2 games. all completely free!
  • andym - November 17, 2010 12:54 p.m.

    What is the reviewer talking about? The story in ACII was truly awful. The game was good despite it's story, not because of it. Decent review otherwise. My only question is whether it still has the ridiculous assassination missions, where you stealthily take someone out, then for some reason you start talking to them as they're dying so all the guards can see you. It wasn't a stealth game, it was a running away one! I thought this was going to be an identical game with few changes, I'm pleasantly surprised. Will probably get it when it becomes cheap.
  • Shinn - November 17, 2010 10:53 a.m.

    I saw a hot blonde Assassin, i'm in.
  • humpiedumpie - November 17, 2010 8:02 a.m.

    Great review! :) I am still not sure to buy this one though, because i will only play the singleplayer. Assassins Creed is just not a game for me to be played in competitive multiplayer. Maybe ill wait till it's half priced :) Still a good game though
  • Defguru7777 - November 17, 2010 4:39 a.m.

    Seems pretty good. I'll pick it up eventually, but not until after Golden Sun: Dark Dawn, Dead Rising 2, and Fallout: New Vegas.

Showing 1-20 of 53 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000