Both games even have little slimy black puddles of evil-ness that must be destroyed unless you want evil health draining goo on your shoes. That's not something you can wipe on the mat outside the front door.
Similarity #8: The endings... or lack thereof
I have no qualms with ruining the end of Alone in the Dark. The game will be celebrating its two year anniversary next month, and you can skip ahead at any time to see what is arguably either the best or worst videogame ending of all time. Basically, you mutter a profanity and walk away from the apocalypse… or you become Satan. It's confusing and nonsensical, and not much of a payoff for the eight or so hours of your life that you can't get back.
Wake, I will not spoil the ending for, but I will say it is almost equally confusing and nonsensical.
Similarity #9: Alan versus Alone
And we cannot ignore the most obvious similarity between the two games. The very reason you will find the games side by side on the shelf at Gamestop is because of their alphabetical proximity. I am, of course, referring to the first word of the title of each game. Alone? Alan? Those words are a mere three letters away from being the same collection of consonants and vowels! Do you really think that is just a coincidence? Actually – it probably is.
What about the rest, though? It cannot be denied that Alan Wake has a better premise, is better written, is prettier to look at and is all around more fun to play than Alone in the Dark. The titles were in development for a long time, and Alone in the Dark could have benefited from more, but it is unlikely, despite the many similarities, that Alan Wake ripped off Alone in the Dark. Wake certainly benefited from the negative feedback that Alone in the Dark encountered. It undoubtedly allowed them to polish many of the elements incorporated into their game, but I chalk it all up to a case of good ideas are good ideas, no matter who is able to show them off first.
GamesRadar is the premiere source for everything that matters in the world of video games. Casual or core, console or handheld - whatever systems you own or whatever genres you love, GamesRadar is there to filter out what's worth your time and to help you get even more from your games. We deliver the best advice, the most in-depth features, expert reviews, and the essential guides for all the top games.