Google+

7 things Donkey Kong Country Returns needs to be authentic

4. These guys

All of ‘em, but honestly, we’d settle for just King K. Rool. Everyone knows Donkey Kong’s true rival is Mario, from back in the Pauline/Jumpman days. But as Donkey Kong Jr. pointed out, nobody really likes seeing Mario portrayed as a bad guy (except maybe us), so Rare wisely decided to give the Kong Klan a different motivation and villain in DKC.


Above: Get these back


Above: From this guy

And it worked. King K. Rool is not the most threatening boss you’ll ever see at first glance, but after he kicks your ass repeatedly, you’ll learn to fear him (and his consistently kick-ass boss music). Furthermore, like any great villain, K. Rool’s got the resilience of a tank, taking endless slapstick-y punishment yet never failing to make it out alive.

Status? … Uh-oh.

As you know by now, developer Rare was the creator of the Donkey Kong Country series, taking the Donkey Kong character copyrighted by Nintendo and essentially giving him his own game universe. According to the United States Copyright Office database (which is actually way cooler to look through than you might think), the entire Donkey Kong Country SNES game was a “work for hire” - Rare was paid to produce a game with Nintendo characters that Nintendo would own all the rights to. So, if Nintendo wanted to, say, roll out another “Donkey Kong Country” game (as they’re doing now), it would be able to without paying Rare a cent.


Above: Rare wasn’t even given credit on its own game’s box until the of DKC was released in 1997. Freelancing can be tough, man!

Rare never copyrighted the characters of K. Rool nor the Kremlings in the DKC universe, because doing so would violate the “work for hire” agreement made with Nintendo.

What all this means is that Nintendo has every legal right to have Donkey Kong square off against the Kremling Klan again in DKC Returns. But Tanabe has flat out said, “There will be no alligators in this game."

Why? Our guess is that Nintendo’s just being polite. Even though Rare is no longer on Nintendo’s payroll, the Kremlings are undoubtedly Rare’s creations; Nintendo using them without permission just because they could would be a little dickish. As much as we bemoan the lack of Kremlings, we have to admit, not taking advantage of its contract is a pretty classy move on Nintendo’s part.


Above: It seems we’ll be getting this Tiki-inspired boss character in DKCR instead

But… now that we think about it, if ownership issues are holding back certain characters of DKC from returning, what will become of…


5. The Kong Crew?

The Kong dynasty is already huge; Rare has had no qualms in the past about adding to the family (DK 64, anyone?) whenever it released a new title. DK’s lineage spans multiple generations, as well as an uncomfortable number of species:

Still, the Kong family, like the Kremlings, is comprised of nearly all Rare-made characters owned by Nintendo. Obviously, Diddy will be in DKCR, but what about the others?

Status:

The official word on this is still mum. According to Tanabe: “There was a direction from Mr. Miyamoto as to up to what point in the series' legacy to draw from, but I think it will be the most fun for people to play it themselves and see who pops up along the way.”

That’s pretty far from the outright “no” we got with the Kremlings. At least someone from the Kong family is popping up along the way, huh? If so, we’re willing to bet our lunch money that that means we’ll be seeing our favorite crotchety old geezer once more. After all, Cranky’s technically got more ties to Nintendo than Rare - according to some versions of series’ canon, Cranky was the same Donkey Kong that kidnapped Pauline all those years ago.

At least, we hope so. We think you’ll agree: DKCR wouldn’t be complete without a little fourth-wall-rupturing snark from good ol’ Cranky. We can already hear him whining, “All this Wii Waggle is making my arthritis act up…”


6. Animal Friends

Even if Expresso the Ostrich was a bit crap, the animal friends in DKC were pretty essential, at least in terms of mixing up the gameplay.  Squawks could fly, hold lights, or shoot coconuts; Rambi could charge through enemies and breakable walls, and Ellie the Elephant could shoot water from her trunk. Sure, some were more fun to use than others, but each animal friend had that spark of personality that made us love them.


Above: Remember Squitter? How Rare made this work is beyond us

Status? We already know that with a lack of underwater levels comes a likely lack of Enguarde the Swordfish, but as for the rest of the animal buddies, we’ve seen nothing. According to Tanabe: "I know people certainly have enjoyed them in the past so we are definitely considering those elements of gameplay. But you'll have to excuse me for keeping this secret for a little while longer."

Still, we’d bet on some animal-riding happening. DK Jungle Beat had both bird-riding and wildebeest-riding, even if those animal friends were not given names or personalities. We’re hoping to see some more familiar faces show up in DKCR, and Tanabe knows we want ‘em, but we’ll have to wait to see what we get.


7. Alliterative Area Aliases

I’ll also settle for level names with lousy rhymes, or with the letter “k” inserted where it doesn’t belong (for komik effekt, of kourse). Oh, Rare humor. You’re so sincere and dopey, like your friend’s goofy dad. Even when you’re trying to be dark and serious, everything about you is so damned likable. Actually, as much as we like Retro Studios, this is personally my biggest sticking point on DKCR. Will it have that Rare-exclusive goofy sensibility, that cartoony, slapsticky magic? Or will it be all brawn and no heart?

 


Above: DK Jungle Beat did an admirable job bringing some personality into DK’s adventure, but it didn’t have much in the way of humor

All we have to go off with Retro Studios is the Metroid Prime trilogy. Freakin’ awesome, but as serious as the plague. So, what can we expect? Comedy gold?

Status? Still up in the air. On the Late Night Show with Jimmy Fallon, Nintendo big-wig Reggie Fils-Aime and Jimmy played through a bit of DKCR’s opening level, which included a cute opening - Jimmy and Reggie had to shake their wii-motes to make Donkey and Diddy burst out of DK’s house. But that’s not quite a joke, is it?

There does seem to be a good deal of personality in the way Donkey and Diddy animate - we like the way the two look when too close to a ledge, or when Diddy walks upright before breaking out into a run. Still, the only real humor in this video comes from watching Jimmy Fallon try to jump on Reggie’s back not once, but twice in the span of a couple seconds.

What do you think? Are we being niggling Nancies? Does Donkey Kong Country Returns have everything you want from a remake? Or do you wish Rare was more involved? Let us know in the comments below!

Aug 22, 2010

E3 2010: 6 reasons we already love Donkey Kong Country Returns
Read why we think Kong will be king on Wii

 


E3 2010: Why wait? Tomorrow’s games reviewed NOW
More future-perfect prognostication from the brightest minds in mind-dom. Or best guesses



Game music of the day: Donkey Kong Country
GR's ongoing tribute to the beloved world of videogame music

39 comments

  • Anduin1 - August 31, 2010 11:51 p.m.

    No Kremlins no buy from me initially, I need to see extensive play testing to see if this worth $$$ or just a rental or a "mod" stonval appointed,
  • lln35 - August 24, 2010 5:05 p.m.

    Hello,everybody,the good shopping place,the new year approaching, click in. Let's facelift bar! ===== http://www.love-shopping.org === Air jordan(1-24)shoes $30 UGG BOOT $50 Nike shox(R4,NZ,OZ,TL1,TL2,TL3) $33 Handbags(Coach lv fendi d&g) $33 Tshirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $16 Jean(True Religion,ed hardy,coogi) $30 2 Sunglasses(Oakey,coach,gucci,Armaini) $12 New era cap $9 Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $18 FREE SHiPPING
  • philipshaw - August 24, 2010 12:32 p.m.

    You have every right to want this stuff in the game,still a bit nervous about this but so I will wait for reviews before buying it
  • ThePigHostage - August 24, 2010 8:27 a.m.

    @jmcgrotty I think it's supposed to say "until the Player's Choice edition of DKC was released".
  • jmcgrotty - August 24, 2010 7:12 a.m.

    Not to seem anal about typos and stuff, but I am curious what is missing in the caption "Rare wasn’t even given credit on its own game’s box until the of DKC was released in 1997." Until what was released?
  • keefster - August 24, 2010 5:05 a.m.

    I can't wait, my wallet is taking a beating with all the games coming out this fall.
  • JDMDrifter - August 24, 2010 2:32 a.m.

    Jesus Christ Newman as soon as I got to the animal friends part I shit my pants in fear for you see I have an extreme fear of spiders and that picture was a bit much. Overall though well written.
  • ThatGuyFromTV - August 24, 2010 2:09 a.m.

    I wouldn't say that a lack of underwater levels means a lack of Enguarde. Retro can make it work if they're creative. For example - say one of the bosses is a Loch Ness monster-type guy, and the only way to damage him is to throw Enguarde at him like a spear. It could work!
  • ThePigHostage - August 23, 2010 9:56 p.m.

    @JNewman Rare could never sue, as they have absolutely zero legal right to the characters (as mentioned in the article). Nintendo owns the characters and can do whatever they want with them. And DK Jungle Climber pretty much was a platformer - though it really doesn't make a difference. So yeah, I just don't see this as a likely reason for the Kremling's exclusion.
  • taterboob - August 23, 2010 6:49 p.m.

    I hate to split hairs...but I'm going to anyway. Diddy's not a chimpanzee. Chimps don't have prehensile tails.
  • garnsr - August 23, 2010 5:10 p.m.

    I never liked Donkey Kong Country much. It came out at the point when I was getting tired of swimming levels, and especially mine carts, and jumping to pick up items floating in the air. It just seemed calculated to be how a game was supposed to be at that point in time.
  • HardlyBirdman - August 23, 2010 2:33 p.m.

    ugh....Kong family......Diddy's a shoe-in, and you're right, the game would be lacking without Cranky......but other than Funky Kong and Dixie, I won't miss a single one of the others if they don't show up. In fact, I think that it would be a selling point.
  • Waldo - August 23, 2010 1:26 p.m.

    If the new badies are any good this could launch a whole new series (I hope). I've always kinda hoped for a co-op DKC though. Me and my bud would always pick a dude and pass the controller when the other died. That kind of team play was really cool. You felt like you were playing even if you weren't. Even my folks were impressed at how great the games looked on the SNES. You know they did something right when your mom tells you how cool the game your playing is!
  • TheElephantManchurianCandidate - August 23, 2010 12:50 p.m.

    Hmm You've made me wonder if I still want this game.
  • JNewman - August 23, 2010 12:47 p.m.

    @ThePigHostage Great point, though I'd throw out there that none of those games you mentioned are platformers, but gimmicky other types of games. If you were Rare and were thinking of suing, you'd have a much weaker case against, say, Donkey Konga than you would with a game that so clearly models DKC's structure (and title, for that matter). Still, good catch!
  • markshell - August 23, 2010 12:40 p.m.

    Diddy Kong was a great game for sure, but it wasn't supposed to have Diddy in it. His addition to the game and title was a last minute thing just to give it a household name so it could sell like it did. That cute little universe had nothing to do with the Donkey Kong Country universe. Magic Carpet Elephants? Wizpig? Timber the tiger? Oh come on.
  • CH3BURASHKA - August 23, 2010 7:08 a.m.

    I was pretty pissed when they said there wouldn't be any crocs. All the enemies so far have been very Wii-friendly, very colorful and purdy. Maybe that's just the Cranky Kong in my talking, but I would very much like them to stick to the roots as close as possible. The tiki boss is retarded, though.
  • slimjim441 - August 23, 2010 4:59 a.m.

    I'm not worried at all. This game is going to be great. I have complete faith in Retro. They did a phenomenal job with the Primes, and I believe they'll do just as good with DKC. There are some things you mentioned that would be kind of disappointing without them, like not including the whole crew, or no Kremlings, but it's not like they would be major down falls. It would be like how everyone was a little bit disappointed when 'The Touch' wasn't in War for Cybertron. Or that Kraid wasn't in Metroid Prime (not by choice, they didn't have the time). Anyway, Retro Studios will not disappoint, and you can bet your last golden banana on that.
  • ThePigHostage - August 23, 2010 1:52 a.m.

    Am I the only one who remembers that Nintendo has been using K. Rool and the Kremlings in several games after Rare's departure? DK King of Swing DK Jungle Climber Donkey Konga He's even a playable character in DK Barrel Blast and Super Mario Sluggers. So I don't see why Nintendo would suddenly think it's inappropriate to use him in this game. There must be some other reason.

Showing 1-20 of 39 comments

Join the Discussion
Add a comment (HTML tags are not allowed.)
Characters remaining: 5000